Criterion Fountain Pen and Pencil Set - Full Size GF Checkerboard, Flexible Fine Nib (Excellent, Restored)
Sheaffer "Guys and Dolls" White Dot Fountain Pen - Lime Green, 1970s, Medium Nib (Excellent, Works Well)
Our Featured Products
Our pen inventory is eclectic and constantly changing. We acquire collections and add new pens to the web site almost every day, and we think you'll find excellent value in our pre-owned and new old stock fountain pens. Our pens are guaranteed to write properly (we do 95% of the restoration ourselves).
Vintage, restored pens
We buy collections regularly, and have hundreds of reasonably priced fountain pens which have been restored to excellent working condition. They, like all our pens, are fully guaranteed. If you are looking for flexible writing, or a classic such as a Parker 51 or a Waterman 52, you'll find we add these models weekly. We have a great reputation with buyers, and we are one of the biggest vintage restored pen sellers in the United States. We offer a no-quibble guarantee. We buy pen collections, and we offer fair prices based on scarcity and condition, so please contact us if you are looking to sell or downsize.
New old stock
Peyton Street Pens has a unique inventory of new old stock by major pen makers such as Sheaffer and Parker. New old stock is defined as new pens which have been in storage for 20-50 years, never used or sold. We guarantee them to work and work well. Sheaffer Imperials and Targas, Parker 45s and 180s -- we've sold thousands of these well made classics.
Modern pre-owned pens
We buy modern collections as well as vintage, so if you're looking for a special Omas, S T Dupont or Pelikan you can find some extraordinary prices on barely used modern high end pens. If what you care about is the writing experience and the qualities of the pen, not the packaging and whether it's been inked, then pre-owned can represent an incredible savings over new retail or even online new prices. With plenty of photos to examine, and our no questions asked guarantee, pre-owned starts to come into focus for a lot of our customers
New writing instruments from modern pen makers
Though we started in the pen business selling restored and new old stock pens, we've recently been having a lot of success with pens made by Ranga and other Indian pen makers. We offer the standard Ranga models as well as some of our exclusive Peyton Street Pens designs such as the Zayante, Monterey and Soquel. Ranga and PSP-Ranga pens are hand made from lovely acrylic and ebonite (hard rubber) materials. Coupled with high quality JoWo nibs and vintage nibs, they offer unique qualities at low prices. We also look for close-outs and special opportunities for our customers. We've found some great bargains in Duke and Pilot that allow us to offer special models at tempting prices.